Referees Report for Research Reports

Referee  (First name)    (Second Name) 

Manuscript (e.g., APJCE/M01)  

Introduction

Context of inquiry is described adequately   Relevant literature is surveyed and cited

Comments

Methodology

Description of methodology is adequate   Choice of methodology is justified and appropriate

Comments

Research Findings

Description of research findings is adequate   Tabulation of data or other means of data presentation  is adequate

Comments

Discussion

Comments

Suitability of Manuscript for Publication

(Please select one option only)

Acceptable with minor corrections  Acceptable after modification  Not acceptable

Comments

List of Typographical Errors (Alternatively fax corrections to the Editor-in-Chief at (64) 7 838 4218)

Send Report